Level: High school
Relationship Structures is useful because it helps individuals understand how to optimize their partnerships by leveraging each other's strengths and skills, improving communication, increasing trust, and aligning mutual goals and values.
<p>The subject of Relationship Structures, particularly cognitive integration in marriage and long-term relationships, offers a fascinating insight into how two individuals can combine their strengths and skills to function as a single, cohesive unit. This dynamic allows partners to offload parts of their cognitive load onto each other, which not only helps in managing daily life tasks more efficiently but also fosters a deeper bond through shared responsibilities and goals. By working together and supporting each other's strengths, couples can enhance their problem-solving capabilities, resulting in a more rewarding and satisfying relationship.</p><p>The study of Relationship Structures is incredibly useful as it offers strategies for couples to optimize their partnership, whether they choose to remain more independent, share responsibilities in specialized domains, or fully integrate their cognitive functions. Understanding these dynamics can lead to more effective communication, increased trust, and a stronger partnership. Furthermore, insights from this subject can provide guidance on navigating conflicts and challenges, ensuring that both partners contribute to and benefit from the relationship, aligning their lives in mutual goals and values.</p>
COGNITIVE INTEGRATION IN MARRIAGE AND LONG-TERM RELATIONSHIPS
One of the greatest benefits of marriage is that it allows partners to act as a single unit and offload parts of their cognitive load and basic life maintenance to each other. The extent to which partners leverage this feature in their relationships varies widely, with some living almost entirely bifurcated lives (separate homes, friends, bills, problems, etc.) and others nearly melding into a single hive-minded person (working side by side, living together, solving nearly all problems jointly, etc.).
While many choose to minimize cognitive integration with their partners, we would go so far as to argue that cognitive integration represents the core value of marriage in modern Western society, as almost everything else a person gets from a relationship—be that sex, love, or childcare—can be achieved through hiring someone or dating, while cognitive integration is only accessible through a long-term relationship with a person.
To be clear, one can cognitively outsource various elements of one’s life to someone who is just on their payroll, and many do exactly that, but doing so is risky. This is a bit like having someone making major strategic decisions at a company who will only work for salary and not equity. An employee who is paid in equity is incentivized to act in the best interest of the company and is less likely to make decisions that are purely selfishly motivated and/or find ways to exploit the company for personal gain. Serious, long-term relationships essentially entail humans making an equity swap with their lives. This is why divorces can be so messy; you, the CEO of your life, must essentially fight for as much of your life’s value as you can take back, with a fellow executive who has a major stake in the business.
There are three extremes of cognitive integration. Every relationship exists within these extremes.
Cognitive Separation
Cognitively separated partners are essentially roommates who have sex, maybe kids or pets, and perhaps (though probably not) some shared income.
Cognitive separation is optimal in cases in which:
1. Partners have no reason to trust each other
2. Each individual prioritizes personal freedom and independence over a relationship
3. At least one partner has a strong ideological belief that prevents them from subverting their sense of self to become part of a unit
Cognitive separation is, ironically, also optimal for relationships in which at least one party’s objective function (driving life purpose) revolves around maximizing personal happiness, power, or social status—even though this approach generates the least happiness, power, and success. In cases in which a partner is ideologically motivated to do whatever is ultimately going to give them the most personal happiness, power, or success, the other partner puts themselves in danger by outsourcing some or all of their cognitive load to this self-interested party. (You see this in almost all domains in life—someone striving for personal happiness or fulfillment will always feel less of it and have a harder time achieving it than someone who cares about other things more—see The Pragmatists Guide to Life for more info on this.)
Cognitive separation features two core benefits:
● It is easy to terminate a relationship in which there is no cognitive integration
● It is more difficult for cognitively separated partners to hurt each other
Cognitive separation yields a higher likelihood of relationship termination. This is not just a matter of low exit barriers; nothing about the relationship encourages the partners to grow in parallel, hence within a few decades, partners often become very different people and grow apart. Fortunately, it is easy to bounce back from a cognitively separated relationship, as all parties have been managing their own lives for the most part. This benefit is non-trivial in an age in which relationship separation can be very painful and damaging from a legal, logistical, and statutory perspective.
Cognitive Siloing
If cognitively separate relationships are akin to hunter-gatherer societies, in which each person more or less knows how to survive on their own, cognitively siloed relationships more closely resemble post-industrial societies, in which each person contributes specialized labor and cannot complete every survival-related task themselves.
Consider the idealized 1950s marriage in which the husband processes all family thought and strategies related to work, investing, big ideas, and world affairs, while the wife processes the family’s thoughts and strategies related to meals, child-rearing, home keeping, and morality.
Whether leveraging this approach in a TradCon-style relationship or some other fashion, the dynamic remains the same: Certain domains of one partner’s life are completely offloaded to another partner. By offloading these large chunks of their lives and minimizing overlap, partners can increase output and skill in the domains in which they specialize and excel, thereby increasing the overall output of the relationship unit.
We do not recommend cognitive siloing among couples in which any partner prioritizes their own happiness or success over the relationship’s or family’s combined goals, values, and objectives. Whereas a cognitively siloed relationship can certainly form among self-interested parties, such setups typically end in disaster for at least one partner with time. This is because when a person silos a part of their life—whether it be their finances, their income, or their children—and give it completely over to another individual, they give that person enormous power to work against their best interest without them noticing.
The effectiveness of this relationship model is that it offers the efficiency gains created by the domain specialization of each party without the dangers of complete cognitive integration. For example, if only one party is responsible for family finances, home repair, or gardening, they can theoretically focus more time building expertise in that task than if it was split between both parties. However, we must specify this is theoretical, as in the few instances in which this has been studied, the data is not as clear as one might imagine.
Cognitive siloing is commonly used to enable relationships in which one partner focuses on housekeeping and child rearing-related tasks while the other focuses on career-related tasks. The science is unclear whether this style of child-rearing has any benefit to children, and a lot of the data seems to indicate it might be actively harmful to children. For roughly every four studies touting the benefits of being raised in a household with a stay-at-home parent, there are five indicating that children who grow up in households with a stay-at-home parent have higher rates of discipline problems, lower mental health scores, and get lower grades on average (these effects are most pronounced in female children).
While these studies seem to be pretty well controlled for things like income and parent education, we suspect this still might be a correlation issue with helicopter parents, narcissists, and mentally unstable parents being more likely to be a stay at home just because they can’t hold a job. It is impossible to control for such factors, so they must bias the data a bit. We, therefore, assume the evidence for and against stay-at-home parenting is more likely to be evenly balanced. No particular approach can be assumed to be superior at this point.
If we take this even balance at face value, it indicates strongly that children are strictly better off when raised in households in which both parents work. This is because the studies that show small benefits to having a stay-at-home parent do not temper these benefits with the benefit of the extra income (children do better in marginally wealthier households). This can be a painful concept to absorb, especially for those who sacrificed careers for what they thought was the best interest of their children. If it makes you feel any better, none of the studies showed a large effect either way, so if you are or were a stay-at-home parent and you didn’t have much-earning potential, you likely did not hurt your children that much by foregoing a career and at least your children were/are statistically much better off than they would be if they had grown up in a single-parent household. Given that the research on this topic seems to swing both ways at pretty even intervals, we also would not be surprised to see it swing back in the other direction in the near future.
At any rate, the potential pitfalls of child-rearing-oriented cognitive siloing can be avoided by ensuring each member is actively contributing toward the relationship’s wealth, influence, and/or power. Divisions, for example, may be made along corporate lines, with partners taking CEO vs. CFO vs. COO positions. Or each partner in a relationship may specialize and rise within a different professional field to protect the relationship from downside risk in recessions.
Both a risk and a benefit of cognitive siloing is that it makes exchanging one partner for another specialist in the same cognitive category fairly easy. For example, it would be easy for a partner to swap out one home-keeping, child-rearing partner for another—or even just hire a nanny and maid.
Those whose specialized value has a time limit are in extremely tenuous positions in such relationships. A child-rearing-specialized female who leveraged physical attractiveness to secure a high-value partner will have little value to her partner and the open market after reaching a certain age. This fact will destabilize her relationship over time. To avoid such dangers, ensure any specialization a partner develops will maintain or increase its value with time. A good example of this might involve one partner focusing on building wealth and the other focusing on building influence (through something like politics)—such a relationship would not put either party in a vulnerable position.
Each partner in a cognitively siloed relationship should regularly audit the value their domain brings to the relationship and take measures to ensure that value does not diminish. Never believe you “lucked out” because your partner handles everything for you. Committing to a partner who handles almost everything for you, from income to chores, puts you in an incredibly vulnerable position. Should that person perish or leave you, you will have next to no value on the open market and be unaccustomed to fending for yourself.
Given the low amount of actual interaction needed for this model to function, it is very easy for cognitively siloed partners to grow apart over time and cease improving themselves. Because their partners may not fully understand all the work, stress, and effort that goes into their specialized work and contribution to the relationship, cognitively siloed partners may also come to feel lonely, unappreciated, and unsupported. Cognitively siloed partners must therefore put a uniquely high effort into communicating about their work and achievements, plus supporting the efforts and accomplishments of their partners.
Cognitive Integration
Whereas cognitive siloing usually involves partners taking on different domains in their lives (e.g., “I’ll work and increase our wealth, you’ll build our influence through a political and media career.”), cognitive integration entails partners dividing responsibility for different stages in the decision-making processes related to some or all domains of their lives (e.g., “I will come up with all proposed solutions, you will vet them, I will make a final call, and then you will execute on our decision.”). In other words, cognitively siloed partners divide responsibility by domain, whereas cognitively integrated partners divide responsibility by stage in the decision making and action-taking process.
When people read our books, they often think some chapters are primarily written by Simone and others by Malcolm. This reveals an assumption that we write the books using a cognitively siloed methodology when in reality we write using a cognitively integrated methodology. We talk about what we are going to write together until we have a rough idea of what it will look like, after which Malcolm writes a rough first draft that Simone turns into something readable, and Malcolm ultimately polishes. This is an example of cognitively integrated writing strategy in that the responsibilities are divided by the stage of the decision-making process rather than the domain.
A cognitively integrated couple may, for example, divide all decisions by complexity (from nuanced detail to big picture decisions), then allow each partner to specialize in one type of decision making. Were Partner A to be tasked with making big picture decisions, they may focus on constantly consuming news media, information, and studies, digesting everything, and ultimately communicating a condensed summary to Partner B. Partner B might then be tasked with using this information to make detail-oriented decisions—information they wouldn’t have been able to collect themselves as their noses are buried in the nuances of the detail-oriented decisions affecting their joint lives. Partner B is permitted by the relationship’s arrangement to genuinely focus on every problem without removing their nose from the details through the understanding that partner A has their head up and is alert to larger trends that could be impacting their up-close analysis.
If the actions of partners in a relationship were to be illustrated as a tree, and the color of the tree’s branches indicated the authority of each member, a cognitively siloed tree’s branches would be all one color or another, whereas a cognitively integrated tree would have branches that are vertically striped.
A fully cognitively integrated couple will not have independent thoughts, opinions, or friends (acquired post-relationship start date). Cognitively integrated partners combine their cognitive pathways to the extent that any interaction they have with the world is partially processed by each partner’s brains.
For this model to be effective, each partner must be completely comfortable surrendering individuality and allowing someone else to think on their behalf. Independent thoughts and opinions remain but are as a rule are subordinate to the thoughts and opinions of the collective. While most initially recoil from this concept, 64% of the men and 41% of the women we polled agreed that their ideal marriage would be one in which their lives are as integrated with those of their partners as possible.
We theorize that cognitively integrated relationships are poorly represented in public because:
1. They only work for partners with unique objective functions and lifestyles, typically allowing the partners to work together in some capacity.
2. The social absolutism of individual empowerment in the 70s and 80s created a hostile environment for a relationship style that does not value the individual.
3. It looks like enmeshment to relationship psychologists—which means they would counsel against it. While superficially similar to enmeshment, cognitively integrated relationships and enmeshed relationships have about as much in common as poly relationships and relationships in which someone enjoys many sexual partners by cheating on a spouse.
Enmeshment is when the emotional state of the group is imposed on the individual and is most common in cognitively siloed relationships. Enmeshment is characterized by emotional manipulation through guilt, shaming, and a lack of respect for an individual's personal boundaries. Think of the cliché societal image we have of the overly dramatic mother asking her daughter how she could so wantonly wound the mother by not yet being married and pregnant. This is enmeshment.
Enmeshment is mandatory emotional integration
Cognitive integration is voluntary intellectual integration
An easy rule of thumb for distinguishing between the two involves checking how partners regard emotions. Enmeshed partners will place importance on emotions and emotional displays, while cognitively integrated partners will often have the utmost contempt for decisions made under the influence of emotional states and treat emotional displays as the height of character weakness. Cognitively integrated couples rarely attempt to suppress emotional states, but accept that emotions are just an accident of our evolution (or in the case of those religiously inclined, a tool of the devil), something to be experienced, accepted, and calmly communicated, but not permitted to become the driving force behind an action or a decision.
Consider a case in which a woman gets slighted by a coworker.
● Enmeshed relationship: The woman guilts her partner for not being as mad about it as she is and spends a half-hour talking about how angry it made her while talking about what a loser the woman who made her angry is and insisting her partner hold the same emotionally charged opinion.
● Cognitively integrated relationship with a secular objective function: The woman would note the anger she felt and, understanding that it may cloud her judgment in future dealings with the coworker, sources her partner’s perspective to help her maintain objectivity in those situations in a manner that serves the relationship’s best interest.
● Cognitively integrated couple with a religious objective function: The woman would note the anger and ask her partner to help her focus on how God would want her to respond in such situations so as not to indulge in hatred and anger.
While we are referring heavily to enmeshment, we don’t believe enmeshment is a real “thing” or at least not as it is characterized by relationship psychologists. Instead, what we believe psychologists are observing is an emotional manipulation tactic that is bolstered by creating an expectation of emotional alignment. This expectation of emotional alignment is holistically secondary to the emotional manipulation and represents a power-wielding tactic commonly deployed by those in a submissive or subordinate position in a relationship. That is why this tactic is used so frequently by narcissistic-yet-traditional women; they want to exert control, but don’t want to take control through an act of dominance due to their traditional views on gender roles, so they do so instead through emotional manipulation, which requires some expectation of emotional mirroring in their target (though this can go two ways—something common in mother-daughter relationships).
We ourselves (Simone and Malcolm) have a mostly cognitively integrated relationship and aside from undergoing the hassle of setting it up (a process that took about two years), we have experienced no discomfort from the dynamic—aside from accidentally signing off emails with the wrong name from time to time.
This is not to say we don’t experience negative interpersonal interactions with each other: Once every couple of months, one of us will fail to live up to the expectations we have set for ourselves as a unit. When this happens, we count on our partner to call attention to the failure so we can take a moment to collectively develop a strategy ensuring we never fail in the same way twice. That said, a partner pointing out an unacceptable failure feels less like an outside attack and more like the voice in your head that chastises you for doing something you knew was stupid.
When someone is in a runaway state of anxiety, fear, or grief, it can overwhelm their cognitive load and prevent them from the mental work required to shake it. When half of someone (their partner) can think clearly, it is much easier to implement a strategy to extricate unwanted emotional states before they fester. In a similar vein, it is very easy to suppress a desire to have “fun” or indulge in self-image-reinforcing activities when a person knows their other half is hard at work.
Of all the couples we know who operate on this model, we cannot think of one that has split up or is not extremely successful in a classical sense—though this is likely not because this model is superior but because a couple must be very well matched and financially secure to even attempt it (everyone we know who operates under this model owns a company with their partner, and we have trouble thinking how it would work if they did not—this also might be why we know more people operating under this model than an average person might, as it is disproportionately represented in married CEOs and married CEOs often know each other).
It is not surprising that cognitively integrated couples tend to be CEOs of the same company, as this was the default style of relationship within the “corporate family” model—in which the partners both raise children together and run a company together from their home—which predates the TradCon model and has dominated the past couple thousand years of Western history. What killed the corporate family model was the rise of the male wage job in an office, which started in the early 1900s and gave birth to the TradCon model. What killed the TradCon was the rise of the female wage job in an office through the 1960s and 1970s. With the rise of the gig economy and work-from-home models of corporate work, we can’t help but wonder if we are on the cusp of seeing the rise of a neo-corporate family model (NeoCorp being a term for an iteration of the corporate family model designed for the 21st century).
As a quick aside, it is technically possible to run a NeoCorp or corporate family model in a cognitively siloed fashion as well; it is just less common.
Cognitively integrated relationships require precise circumstances—specifically:
● Closely aligned objective functions that cannot be self-privileging: In other words, both partners have to have the same purpose to their life, and that purpose cannot be to maximize either of their own happiness (or to maximize anything that privileges one individual's cognitive state).
● A hierarchical model of conflict resolution within the marriage contract: Commands must be executed without hesitation. You might think this requires a great deal of trust in a partner, but in reality, all it requires is trust that one has correctly identified that partner’s goal in life, verified that said goal aligns with their own and established that the partner’s mental acuity is such that they won’t make idiotic decisions.
Though it can squeeze even more productive output from a relationship than the siloed approach, cognitive integration features enormous risks and drawbacks:
● If a person misjudges their partner’s motives, unquestionably submitting some of their cognitive processes to the partner could effectively ruin the persons’ life.
● Traditional employment is difficult, as truly cognitively integrated couples work collaboratively on everything. Even entrepreneurial lifestyles are difficult, as investors often view romantic involvement of co-founders or co-executives to be too great a risk factor (“What will happen to the company when you get divorced?”).
● Productivity plummets when the devices and systems used for cognitive synchronization, such as cloud-based document sharing, CRM systems, and shared calendars, become unavailable.
● The death of one partner can render another significantly less functional than they would be otherwise. Learning how to think totally independently again is a long and difficult process.
Part of Types of Lures.
Learn Relationship Structures free on Parrhesia with an AI tutor, then take the test to prove mastery. Create a free account or browse all skills.