Choose a Culture

Level: Middle school

Choose a Culture helps us explore different ways people understand the world, enriching our perspectives and broadening our understanding of humanity.

About Choose a Culture

<p>Choose a Culture is a fascinating and useful subject because it allows us to explore the diverse ways in which people understand the world and their place within it. Culture is more than just accents, fashion, or traditions; it's a complex web of values and beliefs that shape our identities and influence our behavior in both conscious and subconscious ways. By studying different cultures, we learn to appreciate the unique perspectives and practices that people around the world engage in, which can help enrich our own lives and broaden our understanding of humanity.</p> <p>Understanding culture is also essential because it plays a vital role in defining our identities. The cultures we belong to or are exposed to can offer us a sense of belonging and help solidify our personal beliefs and values. It provides structure and context to our lives, helping us navigate social interactions and personal challenges. Furthermore, as we uncover the insights embedded within our cultural traditions, we not only learn more about others but also about ourselves, making culture a stepping stone towards personal growth and global understanding.</p>

Learning objectives

Mastery requirements

We define culture as an interlocking set of values and schema about the world that interact with superficial identifiers such as accents, mannerisms, and fashion. Culture can play an important role in how we conceptualize our place in the world. 

The right culture can help you (and your family) internalize and strengthen certain elements of your identity. Cohesive cultures provide a series of cues reminding you about your objective function and ideologies. Culture can influence your autopilot behaviour, even when you are forced to operate in suboptimal conditions. 

Think of culture as the costumes and props on a movie or theatrical set. These elements alone will not create a compelling performance, but they certainly help. 

Culture enters people’s lives through a variety of interweaving pathways. While religious and ethnic cultures dominate, cultures born from discrimination and temporary developmental stages also have significant sway, plus many choose to develop cultures of their own, intentionally establishing new traditions for themselves and their kin.


Culture and Religion

Religion relates to us in three distinct ways:

• As a source for defining an objective function

• As a source for building an ideological tree

• As a source of cultural predilections, traditions, and identity

It is possible to have 1 & 2 without 3 and vice versa. For example, a person may believe a religion while simultaneously believing that its culture and traditions corrupt that religion’s prescribed objective function. This can be seen in the disgust with which some fundamentalist sects regard traditions like Santa Claus and the Easter Bunny. A truly pragmatic religious devotee will take inventory of their objective function and test it against traditional practices associated with their religion, discarding those which impede their ability to maximize their objective function. For example, they may ask, “Does celebrating Easter with my kids bring them closer to God?” and find the answer is no. 

Conversely, many stop believing in their religion as a source of purpose or as an explanation for how the world operates while still drawing from it as a source of traditions and cultural identity. A prominent example of this is the “secular Jew,” someone who maintains a Jewish identity and incorporates Jewish traditions into their lives while maintaining a functionally atheistic worldview. 

We, Simone and Malcolm, fall in this category. While atheistic in both our objective functions and ideological trees, we are relatively strict Calvinists when it comes to culture. We even identify as “Secular Calvinists” over identities like “atheist.” You could argue the entire Pragmatist’s Guide to Life is so heavily influenced by a Secular Calvinist perspective that it is, at its core, just a prescription for how a Secular Calvinist should approach life. 

If we believe that Calvinism does not present a compelling objective function or explanation of how the world works, why would we be attracted to its cultural mores? 

Only recently did humans have sufficient information to rival theistic hypotheses when exploring the origins of life and the universe. In contrast, our cultural traditions are the product of hundreds of centuries of cultural evolution. Cultures contain insights that cannot easily be uncovered a priori. For example, almost every religion on earth has some sort of arbitrary self-denial ritual (Lent, Ramadan, the Sabbath, etc.). Many atheists viewed these traditions as pointless until about a decade ago. Now we know that inhibitory pathways in our brains need regular exercise to stay strong and if they are not regularly exercised through systematic and arbitrary self-denial, we may see virtues like mental control and grit erode while certain vices—such as anger and anxiety—snowball.

How much of what we inherit from our family comes from genes vs culture is up to debate. What is not debatable is that we do inherit traits from our family. A family’s religious culture can be fine-tuned over generations, helping members of each generation optimize as people. Our Calvinist tradition, for example, imparts an extreme distrust of excess: indulgences in positive or negative emotional states as well of financial luxuries. While we can’t be sure of the method of action, adopting this mindset significantly improves our overlay states and efficiency. 

We have anecdotally noticed a correlation between rejecting cohesive cultural identities/traditions and experiencing more frequent, intense negative overlay states (though, it is possible that being unhappy causes a person to question culture more aggressively). 

We are not opposed to forging new ways of living—society is better for people who innovate new cultures because they move things forward. That said, cultural trailblazers often sacrifice their own happiness to run what are essentially “cultural experiments”. The mad inventor would not be “mad” if he didn’t occasionally end up holding a now-empty test tube with soot on his face and his eyebrows singed off. Because they are forging a new path, those who move the furthest from their traditions (either voluntarily or because society cut them off) may struggle more to find contentment and emotional stability in their lives.  

Ethnic Cultures

While ethnic cultures might be seen as overlapping with cultures of groups facing discrimination, they stand on their own (Han culture, for example, may be marginalized in the USA, but not in China). A common crisis among those who live by ethnic cultures arises from the mismatch between the ethnic culture with which they grew up (internal to their family) and the “true, historic version” of this ethnic culture. 

Cultures evolve to fit their context. A more historically accurate execution of cultural traditions may work better for you, but ultimately it is your choice. There is no such thing as the “correct” manifestation of a culture. This is especially important to acknowledge given how frequently people discover what they believed to be traditional cultural practices are, in actuality, artificial previsions of that culture that had been marketed to them through media. 

Cultures Born from Discrimination

As we discuss in greater depth in The Pragmatist’s Guide to Sexuality, discrimination can drive those who face public persecution to commune with each other in private. This can foster the development of new, underground cultures through a process called “cultural drift,” which has produced many now-iconic, influential, and cohesive cultures complete with unique traditions, values, and mannerisms (think: LGBT culture).

While these cultures may have a place in your life if you fall within an associated discriminated group, they are not a mandate. It is OK to be part of a historically persecuted group and not feel personal affinity toward the culture that formed around it. We say this, as a feeling of disconnect between an element of one’s identity and that attribute’s associated culture can cause significant cognitive dissonance. You are not more or less “X” because you participate (or don’t participate) in “X” culture. 

Evanescent Teen Culture

Many teens experience an innate desire to reject their parents’ culture while simultaneously feeling very attuned to the feelings and caprices of peers their age. This often drives adolescents to “shop” for new cultures, only to return to a modified version of their ancestral culture upon reaching adulthood and having kids of their own (unless they experience systematic discrimination, which shifts identification toward the culture of their persecuted group). 

This cycle produces evanescent teen cultures—or cultures specifically marketed to teens. Consider goth, emo, or e-girl culture—each of which features distinctive accents, dress, values, mannerisms, literature, and traditions. Evanescent teen cultures are hardly novel—consider dandy/macaroni culture as an older example. 

Adolescent cultures evolve much faster than mainstream or religious cultural traditions, typically die out after a few decades, and are not conducive to happy, successful lifestyles. Rather than optimize for traditional success, contentment, or flourishing, evanescent teen cultures typically emphasize personal agency and uniqueness (highly rewarded attributes among teens). 

Constructing Culture

What if you want to attempt to build your own family culture or modify an existing cultural schema? 

Culture is best transmitted through traditions and media. For example, to develop a bespoke culture that reinforces our unique values and ideologies, we modified existing holidays and created a few of our own, focusing on rituals that appeal to kids (traditions often live or die based on how much kids like them—this is why Halloween thrives while Lent languishes). We also curated a selection of materials to either read to our kids or regularly watch together and discuss, each of which features its own lessons related to our family values and ideologies. 

Culture is just another aspect of a well-rounded education. It is our job to provide a rich upbringing for our kids without getting too experimental and endangering their ability to thrive. (We might put together a book on this one day.) 

Part of Choosing How You Want Others to See You.

Learn Choose a Culture free on Parrhesia with an AI tutor, then take the test to prove mastery. Create a free account or browse all skills.